Electric bike or electric scooter: which to choose?
With the rise of eco-friendly urban transportation, more and more city dwellers are turning to solutions like the electric bike and the electric scooter. These two options offer unique advantages, but which one is the best for you? In this article, we will explore the characteristics, advantages, disadvantages, and suitable uses of each vehicle to help you make an informed choice.
Essential criteria to consider
Before diving into the details of each vehicle, it is important to identify the key criteria that will guide your choice:
- Daily distance traveled: What is the typical distance of your trips?
- Terrain: Is your environment mostly flat or does it have hills?
- Comfort: What level of comfort are you looking for in your trips?
- Storage: Do you have enough space to store your vehicle?
- Budget: How much are you willing to invest in an electric vehicle?
The electric bike: a classic revisited
Advantages of the electric bike
The electric bike, often seen as an upgraded version of the traditional bike, has several advantages:
| Pedal assistance | The electric motor helps with pedaling, making trips less tiring, especially over long distances or hilly terrain. |
| Autonomy | Generally, electric bikes offer a greater range than scooters, with models reaching up to 100 km per charge. |
| Versatility | Whether in urban or rural areas, the electric bike is suitable for various types of terrain, including country paths. |
| Comfort | Electric bikes are usually equipped with comfortable seats and suspension systems, making them ideal for longer trips. |
| Health | Even though the motor assists pedaling, you still need to pedal, which helps maintain a regular physical activity. |
Take a look at our article detailing the benefits of electric cycling in 2024!
Disadvantages of the electric bike
Despite its many advantages, the electric bike also has some drawbacks:
| Weight | Electric bikes are heavier than traditional bikes, which can be problematic for transporting or storing. |
| Bulkiness | Their size requires significant storage space, which can be a challenge in apartments or small offices. |
| Maintenance | Electric bikes require regular maintenance, especially with the battery and motor. |
| Cost | The price of an electric bike is often higher than that of an electric scooter, which can be a deterrent for some users. |
We've also published an article listing the disadvantages of electric bikes in 2024!
The electric scooter: the urban mobility ally
Advantages of the electric scooter
The electric scooter attracts with its practicality and ease of use. Here are its main advantages:
| Maneuverability | Light and compact, the electric scooter is easy to maneuver through crowded streets. It weaves easily between cars and pedestrians. |
| Portability | Easily foldable, it can be transported on public transport or stored under a desk. |
| Ease of use | Just step on and go. No need to pedal, which can be an advantage for those who don’t want to sweat. |
| Cost | Generally, electric scooters are more affordable than electric bikes, making them accessible to a broader audience. |
| Less maintenance | Electric scooters generally require less maintenance than bikes, as they are mechanically more simple. |
Disadvantages of the electric scooter
The electric scooter, despite its practicality, is not without flaws:
| Limited range | Most electric scooters offer a shorter range than electric bikes, averaging 20 to 40 km per charge. |
| Reduced comfort | Due to the small wheel size and lack of suspension on some models, rides on cobblestones or rough roads can be uncomfortable. |
| Limited speed | While some scooters can reach speeds of 25 km/h, their speed is still lower than that of electric bikes. |
Restricted use | The scooter is mainly suitable for urban trips on flat terrain. It is not recommended for long distances or hilly roads. |
Which vehicle for which use?
The choice between an electric bike and an electric scooter depends primarily on your lifestyle, needs, and environment.
For daily city commutes
If you are making short daily trips in an urban environment, the electric scooter may be your best ally. It is ideal for quickly getting from point A to point B without worrying about parking. Its practicality also makes it an excellent choice for those who take public transport in addition.
For long distances and varied routes
If your trips are longer or involve varied terrain (hills, unpaved roads), the electric bike is probably more suitable. Its range and comfort will allow you to cover more distance without excessive effort. Plus, if you like to stay active, the electric bike offers the opportunity to combine exercise and mobility.
Check out our 7 tips for boosting the range of your electric bike!
For comfort seekers
If comfort is your priority, the electric bike wins with its equipment (padded seat, suspension) that better absorbs the shocks and vibrations of the road. The scooter, while practical, is more rudimentary in this aspect.
For a limited budget
If your budget is limited, the electric scooter is generally more accessible. You can find good models starting at €300, while quality electric bikes often start at around €1000.
Conclusion: electric bike or electric scooter?
Ultimately, the choice between an electric bike and an electric scooter will depend on your specific needs. The electric bike is ideal for those looking for a versatile mode of transport, capable of covering long distances while offering a certain comfort. The electric scooter, on the other hand, is perfect for short urban trips, requiring little effort and offering great maneuverability.
At Doctibike, we understand that every user has different needs. That's why we recommend carefully defining your priorities before making a choice. Whether you opt for an electric bike or an electric scooter, the essential thing is to choose the vehicle that will make your trips more enjoyable and more efficient.
